10 Best Prophy Pastes 2025

Looking for the best prophy pastes? Look no further than our Top 10 Prophy Materials list! We reviewed and scored many products in the prophy materials category, ranging from a 7 up to a high-scoring 9.7. But there was one brand that stood out from the rest: Prophy Magic. Their Flavored Gluten-Free Prophy Paste is a non-splatter formula that's perfect for polishing and stain removing, with fluoride release and an easy rinse off. And with a minty flavor, you'll actually look forward to your next cleaning! Don't settle for less – try Prophy Magic today and experience the magic for yourself.