10 Best Handmade Wallet Inserts 2025

If you're like most people, you probably carry around a wallet stuffed with various cards and IDs. But what happens when you run out of space? Enter handmade wallet inserts - the perfect solution for those in need of extra storage. In our search for the top ten wallet inserts in the wallets and bag accessories category, we reviewed and scored many products in the wallet inserts subcategory, ranging from a 7.1 score up to a 9.8 score. But there was one clear winner: THEMEROL's "Gifts for Dad from Daughter Fathers Day Birthday Gifts for Dad Who Have Everything I Love My Dad to My Dad Wallet Card Stocking Stuffers Christmas Valentine Day Easter" insert. Not only does this insert provide ample storage space, but it also makes for a heartfelt gift for your dad. Trust us, he'll love it. Excited to learn more about our top picks? Keep reading to find out why these handmade wallet inserts are a must-have accessory.