10 Best Handmade Shaving Creams, Lotions & Gels 2025

Looking for a luxurious, high-quality, and all-natural shaving experience? Look no further than our top ten list of handmade shaving creams, lotions & gels. We've scoured the market to bring you the very best products in the shaving & hair removal category, ranging from a 7.9 to a whopping 9.7 score. And our number one pick? None other than Crazy Goat Soaps' Whipped Shave Butter. Infused with sweet vanilla and whipped goat milk, this paraben-free shave lotion is perfect for dry and sensitive skin, thanks to its ultra-moisturizing blend of organic shea and cocoa butter. Trust us, once you try it, you'll never go back to your old shaving routine. Ready to elevate your shaving game? Keep reading for our full top ten list of must-try handmade shaving creams, lotions & gels.