10 Best Handmade Piercing Gauges & Plugs 2025

Looking for a unique addition to your piercing collection? Look no further than our top 10 list of Handmade Piercing Gauges & Plugs in the Piercing Jewelry category. We've reviewed and scored many products in this category, with scores ranging from 7.2 up to an impressive 9.6. The top-rated item is from Defiant Jewelry, known for their high-quality and visually stunning pieces. Their Handmade Frosted Holographic on Rose Gold Plugs come in a variety of sizes, from 16g to 1 inch, making them the perfect fit for any piercing. The frosted holographic design on the rose gold base creates a unique and eye-catching look. Trust us, these plugs will have all eyes on you. Don't wait, check out our full list to find the perfect addition to your collection.