10 Best Handmade Dog Toys 2025

As a dog lover and toy expert, I have reviewed and scored numerous handmade dog toys in the Toys category, specifically in the Dogs subcategory. From squeaky balls to plush bones, I can confidently say that the New Puppy Gift Personalized Dog Toy Bone Plush Pillow Custom Boy Girl from RomeoShop takes the cake with a whopping score of 9.7! But don't just take my word for it, we've got a whole top ten list of high quality handmade dog toys that are sure to please even the pickiest pup. And while we found products ranging from a 7.2 score up to our top scorer, our number one pick is truly a cut above the rest. So, if you're looking for the perfect gift for your furry friend, or just want to spoil them a little (who are we kidding, they deserve it!), be sure to check out our list and get ready to see some tail-wagging excitement!