10 Best Handmade Cat Toys 2025

If you're the kind of person who wants to give your feline friend the best of the best, you're in the right place. We've reviewed and scored many handmade cat toys in the Toys category, and have found products ranging from a 7.6 score up to a 9.7 score. But, when it comes to the top spot, one brand stands out above the rest: Made By Tricia. Their Command, Science or Engineering Delta organic catnip cat toy made from wool-blend felt is the clear winner in our eyes. Not only is it adorable and handmade, but it's also filled with organic catnip sure to drive your kitty wild. Trust us, your cat will thank you for choosing Made By Tricia. So what are you waiting for? Check out our list of the top 10 handmade cat toys and give your furry friend something special to play with.