10 Best Handmade Aftershaves 2025

Step into the world of luxurious grooming with our top 10 handmade aftershaves for shaving and hair removal. We reviewed and scored many products in the aftershave category, and we found products ranging from a 7.1 score up to an exceptional 9.9 score. Our top pick is the Rustic Charm Farm Goat Milk Aftershave Lotion in the Bay Rum scent. This handmade aftershave is the perfect addition to your grooming routine, leaving your skin feeling refreshed and moisturized. Rustic Charm Farm's commitment to using natural ingredients and traditional techniques ensures a high-quality product that stands out from the rest. Indulge in the ultimate grooming experience and explore our top 10 handmade aftershaves for shaving and hair removal.