10 Best Cat & Dog Toys This Season 2025

Looking for the perfect toy to keep your furry friend entertained this season? Look no further than the Whisker City® Pickle Cat Toy. With a top score of 9.9, this toy stands out among the competition for its innovative design and high-quality construction. The catnip-filled center boosts excitement and engagement, while the playful pickle shape adds a quirky twist to swatting and pouncing. Its lightweight build makes it easy for cats to bat, chase, and carry around, providing endless hours of fun. The soft plush texture is gentle for playful bites and cuddles, and the fun green color grabs your cat's attention during playtime. Treat your feline companion to the best with the Whisker City® Pickle Cat Toy and watch them enjoy hours of entertainment and stimulation.

By Josef Dean

Fact Checked

Updated on October 31, 2025 8:26 AM

Best Seller

9.8

Joyhound® Crazy Comfy Realistic Pheasant Dog Toy - Plush, Squeaker

Dog Toy Design gives pups a playful, lifelike pheasant they can chase, cuddle, and carry around.
Silly Squeaker Inside adds a fun sound that sparks excitement during play.
Crinkling Texture keeps dogs curious with gentle noise that encourages interaction.
Soft Plush Exterior offers a soothing, comforting surface perfect for naps and snuggles.
PetSmart Exclusive introduces a new Joyhound favorite found only in store.

PetSmart

Check Price

9.3

Arcadia Trail® Toss-and-Fetch Dog Toy

Floats for easy retrieval during lakeside or poolside play
Water Resistant Build holds up well during splashy adventures
Toss and Fetch Design keeps active dogs engaged outdoors
Durable Material stays strong through repeated throws
PetSmart Exclusive offers a fun toy you can only find in store

PetSmart

Check Price

OMG Surprise® Santa Dog Toy

Rip It Up Design encourages dogs to tear, shred, and enjoy every chaotic moment
Two Toys in One gives pups an outer layer to destroy and a hidden toy to uncover
Shreddable Outer Shell adds irresistible texture for playful destruction
Fluffy Middle Layer keeps the ripping fun going as they dig through the stuffing
Surprise Vinyl Squeaker reveals a silly squeaky toy waiting inside for extra excitement

PetSmart

Check Price

8.4

Merry & Bright® 12-Pack Assorted Holiday Toys

Merry and Bright 12 Pack offers a festive mix of toys for nonstop holiday fun
Catnip Infused Toys spark excitement and encourage natural hunting behavior
Interactive Play Support helps strengthen bonding moments with your cat
Active Engagement Design keeps kitties moving, pouncing, and entertained
Feathery Details add extra flair that cats love to bat and chase

PetSmart

Check Price

8.3

Whisker City® Lizard Cat Toy

Cat Toy Design gives your kitty a colorful character to chase and pounce on
Dinosaur Theme adds a playful look that stands out during playtime
Catnip Infusion boosts excitement and keeps your cat engaged
Soft Lightweight Build makes it easy for cats to bat and carry
PetSmart Exclusive offers a fun toy found only in store

PetSmart

Check Price

7.9

Merry & Bright® 3-Pack Plush Teasers

Merry and Bright 3 Pack Teasers brings a festive trio of plush toys for swatting and pouncing
Catnip Infused Toys spark curiosity and encourage natural hunting instincts
Interactive Play Boost helps strengthen bonding during shared play sessions
Active Engagement Design keeps your cat moving, chasing, and entertained
Holiday Color Mix adds cheerful seasonal flair in blue, white, red, green, and silver

PetSmart

Check Price

7.6

Joyhound® Rip Roarin' Tough Pizza Dog Toy - Tough Plush

Super Squeaker Inside adds exciting sound play that keeps dogs engaged
Ripstop Material helps withstand rough chewing and tugging
Puncture Resistant Fabric gives extra durability for aggressive chewers
Strong Cross Stitching reinforces seams for long lasting toughness
Toughest Toy Design delivers a rugged build made for big, energetic dogs

PetSmart

Check Price

7.4

Whisker City® Ball Track & Scratcher Cat Toy

Catnip Included draws your kitty in and keeps their curiosity high
Furniture Scratch Reduction gives cats a better outlet so your home stays protected
Exercise and Stimulation encourages active play and mental engagement
Ball Track Fun keeps paws busy with nonstop swatting and chasing
Refillable Scratcher offers long lasting use with a replaceable scratching surface

PetSmart

Check Price

7.3

Joyhound® Boss Bones Femur Chew Dog Toy

Nylon and Wood Blend offers a durable chew made for moderate chewers
Instinct Satisfying Design supports natural chewing habits in a positive way
Faceted Grooved Surface helps clean teeth while your dog chews
Easy Grip Ridges make the toy simple for dogs to hold during play
Gentler Material Feel provides a softer chew experience compared to standard nylon toys